Clone websites - Q1 25 Review

I put four leading AI website builders to the test by asking them to clone Vercel.com - a site with some complex graphics but a fairly common layout overall.

The Contenders

1. v0.dev - Vercel's own no-code AI website maker

2. lovable.dev - A no-code AI website builder with full-stack capabilities

3. same.dev - An emerging tool with autonomous capabilities

4. makereal.tldraw.com - A Figma-like tool for building interactive components, including websites

Results at a Glance

Key Findings

v0.dev

Surprisingly, Vercel's own tool struggled the most with replicating its parent company's website. Many images failed to render properly, with alt tags visibly displaying instead of the expected graphics. While the code structure was clean, the visual result was disappointing.

lovable.dev

The standout performer in this comparison, lovable.dev handled complex graphics in a clever way by substituting stock images where it couldn't replicate the originals. This approach led to a positive user experience despite not perfectly cloning the original assets. Its full-stack capabilities and responsive design further enhanced its lead over the competition.

same.dev

Despite its intriguing autonomous approach, same.dev ultimately failed to deliver a satisfactory clone. While it required minimal guidance, the results were too inconsistent and incomplete to be useful for replicating a complex site like Vercel.com.

makereal.tldraw.com

This Figma-like tool takes a component-focused approach rather than attempting full page cloning. Its performance in this specific test was neither notably impressive nor disappointing compared to the other tools.

Conclusion

In this comparison, lovable.dev emerged as the clear winner with its clever approach to handling complex graphics and solid overall performance. The choice depends on your specific needs:

• For the best overall cloning experience: lovable.dev

• If you need interactive components: makereal.tldraw.com

YT demo below.